HomeНовости и политикаRelated VideosMore From: TIME

The Monica Lewinsky Scandal: A Visual Timeline Of The Events 20 Years Later | TIME

1534 ratings | 168227 views
In 1998, Americans were divided over Bill Clinton's affair with a White House intern. In the 20 years since, those feelings have only grown more complicated. Subscribe to TIME ►► http://po.st/SubscribeTIME Get closer to the world of entertainment and celebrity news as TIME gives you access and insight on the people who make what you watch, read and share. https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL2EFFA5DB900C633F Money helps you learn how to spend and invest your money. Find advice and guidance you can count on from how to negotiate, how to save and everything in between. https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLYOGLpQQfhNKdqS_Wccs94rMHiajrRr4W Find out more about the latest developments in science and technology as TIME’s access brings you to the ideas and people changing our world. https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLYOGLpQQfhNIzsgcwqhT6ctKOfHfyuaL3 Let TIME show you everything you need to know about drones, autonomous cars, smart devices and the latest inventions which are shaping industries and our way of living https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL2862F811BE8F5623 Stay up to date on breaking news from around the world through TIME’s trusted reporting, insight and access https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLYOGLpQQfhNJeIsW3A2d5Bs22Wc3PHma6 CONNECT WITH TIME Web: http://time.com/ Twitter: https://twitter.com/TIME Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/time Google+: https://plus.google.com/+TIME/videos Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/time/?hl=en Magazine: http://time.com/magazine/ Newsletter: time.com/newsletter ABOUT TIME TIME brings unparalleled insight, access and authority to the news. A 24/7 news publication with nearly a century of experience, TIME’s coverage shapes how we understand our world. Subscribe for daily news, interviews, science, technology, politics, health, entertainment, and business updates, as well as exclusive videos from TIME’s Person of the Year, TIME 100 and more created by TIME’s acclaimed writers, producers and editors. The Monica Lewinsky Scandal: A Visual Timeline Of The Events 20 Years Later | TIME https://www.youtube.com/user/TimeMagazine
Html code for embedding videos on your blog
Text Comments (272)
Adam Brady (10 days ago)
Its like a Gary Pucket song...
Tee Carr (1 month ago)
Monica Lewinsky is just an opportunist... and its infuriating! As an ADULT, fully aware - including the fact that she was messing with a married man - she CHOSE to engage in a sexual relationship with Clinton! HER decision!! Then, years later, she tries to take advantage of that situation by trying to hang her flag with a legitimate, meaningful movement, #MeToo, in order to glean attention again. She is utterly DESPICABLE and without conscience. DETESTABLE and UNRESPECTABLE!! 👎🏻🤬🤮👎🏻
Max (1 month ago)
Worst president ever
The Wackness (1 month ago)
Let the man and woman ljve
kumiv (1 month ago)
*Molly and that whiskey that’s Monica Lewinsky* ~ G-Eazy 2014
korikakumei (1 month ago)
TRUMP HAS DONE WAY WORSE THAN BILL. WHY ISN'T HE IMPEACHED YET???!!
Carmen Gomez (1 month ago)
Anything Better Than Hilary At This Point
Teejay Vergara (1 month ago)
Consensual or not, it is still a prime example of the abuse of power. She was an INTERN and he was the PRESIDENT.
Huzair Kalia (1 month ago)
Hillary sucks..... but Monica sucks better
weiwen (1 month ago)
real life olivia pope 3:01
Osvaldo Morales (1 month ago)
Bill Clinton was THAT man
Jessica N (1 month ago)
Even the name of this still reeks of sexism. She wasn’t our president, she didn’t lie to her country. Give her a fucking break already. It’s Bill Clinton’s scandal.
Bill Clinton (1 month ago)
I DID NOT HIT THAT IT'S NOT TRUE IT'S BULL SHIT I DID NOT HIT HER I DID NOTTTTT
Treshan Fernando (1 month ago)
Hii
Jenny H (1 month ago)
what a shitty friend! who tapes conversations with close friends??🤷🏻‍♀️
TJ (1 month ago)
Jenny H Omarossa
Ambereigh (1 month ago)
Still to this day I do not understand why ANYBODY cared about this shit. The dumbest thing to be worry about.
NH4 Ci (1 month ago)
HAHA how does that right wing conspiracy theory feel Hillary?
Нилл (1 month ago)
He clearly is a perv, and Hillary is just a power hungry side bitch. She doesn’t care about her husband’s victims, she doesn’t care about American people, or justice. All she wants is the power and money from rich donors. This is how females sociopath looks like. Just a perfect example
Yiannnis K. (1 month ago)
Clinton was hot. I would suck his dick back then anytime
Maya Winifred (1 month ago)
Why are captions not available? Please make these closed captioned
Sincerely Eccentric (1 month ago)
So, I read this title as what’s happened in the last 20 years since the scandal. Like updates on all parties involved. But ok. Maybe next time.
Jacob Custer (1 month ago)
TIME: invest in a microphone
Aiden G (1 month ago)
The Clinton's should have gone away the day he got impeached
Generic Guy (1 month ago)
Whatever happened, Bill Clinton was a good man. Under his leadership usa experience unprecedented growth and peace
Natan Miksic (7 days ago)
+madfury Well at that time Serbs (Milošević in particular) had it coming.
madfury (1 month ago)
Tell that to the Serbs bombed under his order (such as Trump's wife, hence their hate to the Clinton's).
A T90 (1 month ago)
"He Monica Lewinsky all ovah mah gownnn." ~ Beyonce
Roche Carter (26 days ago)
😂😂😂😑😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Rose (1 month ago)
nokia6630videos *on
CWA (1 month ago)
Clinton is the Greatest. Got head in the Oval Office
mike devaney (1 month ago)
"Although what I said was legally accurate.....I did not volunteer certain information" haha what a beautiful language we have!
Katherine Collins (1 month ago)
Again and again!!!
mike devaney (1 month ago)
Her close friend was recorder her? What a bitch
mike devaney (1 month ago)
I'd let her suck my knob......
Grace Kemmy (1 month ago)
It’s truly crazy to see how the Republican Party put themselves on such a moral high ground for clinton’s scandal. But now our president, Trump has done seriously way worse than this and more and the republicans turn a blind eye. It’s gross
Lauren Wisteria (1 month ago)
Bill Clinton: Innocent until proven guilty despite media's efforts to ignore the women and evidence. Kavanagh: Guilty until proven innocent despite media's best efforts to make him out to be a gang rapist. Riding on the #Metoo movement to get people to think emotionally versus logically and ignore Due Process.
Melissa Salinas (1 month ago)
So why did they give money to that lady?????????
Daenerys Targaryen (1 month ago)
Linda ain’t shit
KYLEHAZE (1 month ago)
It’s all Donald trumps fault
Yousif Omer (1 month ago)
I would smash that she’s hot
Celebrity ASMR (1 month ago)
How did they ORIGINALLY find out about Bill Clinton encounter with Monica Lewisnky? Was it caught on security footage?
Felicia Strickland (19 days ago)
Celebrity ASMR Linda Tripp
100k with no videos? (1 month ago)
Ever since Bill Clinton was still in office with Monica Lewinsky feeling on his... *NUT-SACK*
Finn Green (1 month ago)
And georgie stephononothingnonomous Skips through professing no knowledge of this sleazeball’s antics and mugs it up on daytime tv with his little fan club of starstruck housewives ... How ironic
Tonyiscool (1 month ago)
All he did was clap some cheeks though
Smelly Jelly Studios (1 month ago)
Tonyiscool it was only a beej no cheeks were clapped
yt98 (1 month ago)
All i know is he did tap that a** at least once.
Patrick (1 month ago)
1:47... this picture... Hilary's look... :D :D well, well, well...
TheFourthWinchester (1 month ago)
As an outsider, as a brown guy, I have to say Trump is looking way better than the past Democrat presidents of the USA who solely waged wars on false basis, sexually abused women, lied to the public for years. Atleast, Trump pays for the sex and everyone knows when he is lying or doesn't know better and doesn't wage false wars and tells it like it is (aka, Saudi money deal being more important than a journalist's life).
Orhan Orhan (1 month ago)
So much trouble cause someone couldn't hold his dick in his pants.
Ken (1 month ago)
Bill “i did not have sexual relations with that woman” clinton
Frances Zapata (1 month ago)
Please include closed captions so that the information is accessible to everyone
Wolf (1 month ago)
Don't lie, we all only know who Monaco Lewinsky is from eminem
Jack bmx (1 month ago)
I love political history but I never knew that Bill Clinton was technically impeached 🤣
542mixie12 (1 month ago)
JFK slept with Marilyn monroe too I don’t know why this was such a big issue
NPC #1337 (1 month ago)
Bill got topped off in the oval office. An American hero.
LU DEL (1 month ago)
Clinton wanted to be like JFK. JFK was a real pimp back in the day.
Michael Gray (1 month ago)
And they thought they were going to get back in the white house
DarkChocolate33 (1 month ago)
Republicans only wanted Bill Clinton out of office because he was doing such a good job. Everyone's paycheck was increasing, he solved the problems that George HW Bush left him and was so popular....even better than Obama when it came to economic factors(DADT, DMA and crime bill sucks). Him fucking Monica was okay because it was consensual and was his prerogative to not tell the American people who he was fucking. I'm so sick of "Christian" Conservatives saying shit like "Liberals need to stop asking what happens in Trump's bedroom" when they clearly want to know every damn thing that Bill Clinton is doing(same thing with homosexuals). Hypocritical fucks. This impeachment trial was nothing more than a failed coup d'teat.
rosana conta3 (1 month ago)
Bandidos
Saurabh Singh (1 month ago)
She was just doing her "JOB "
Maryam Mirza (1 month ago)
Ohh so whats happening now to the Clintons is Karma!
Killuminati1991 (1 month ago)
Darn it got excited by “Visual” in the title
ZeroWolf (1 month ago)
Lewinsky has gotten slimmer and hotter with age
Sun Shine (1 month ago)
I remember quagmires confession after seeing Bill Clinton’s confession ...😂😂
Raphaël D (1 month ago)
this scandal is nothing compared to the many Trump'scandals. Clinton lied 1 time, Trump lies every day.
Нилл (1 month ago)
Raphaël D here is one “In 1992, Gennifer Flowers stated that she had a relationship with Clinton that began in 1980. Flowers at first denied that she had an affair with Clinton, but later changed her story. After Clinton at first denied having a relationship with Flowers on 60 Minutes, he later admitted that he had a sexual encounter with Flowers.”
啊啊啊 (1 month ago)
That’s true, but both are wrong. One being more wrong does not excuse the other.
Raphaël D (1 month ago)
​+Нилл ok when were the other times ? proofs ? facts ?
Raphaël D (1 month ago)
+TheFourthWinchester I don't speak about that concerning Trump. Trump lies about everything. Recently he just said that Wall Street reopened the day after 9/11/ Wich is false.
Ramirexgabo (1 month ago)
Why haven’t this be recommended before to me, fucking YouTube man...
Ravindi P.L (1 month ago)
omg is it really that hard to just stay loyal to your wife?
Garden Girl (16 days ago)
Depends on what the definition of "is" is!
nostril damus (1 month ago)
if your options are really great then its very hard !!(pun intended)
Treshan Fernando (1 month ago)
+Pavani M loserr
Pavani M (1 month ago)
hi
HAIZSQUAD (1 month ago)
*I DID NOT HAVE SEXUAL RELATIONS WITH THAT WOMAN*
Bloop 545 (1 month ago)
So the first thing Hillary did was call it a 'right wing conspiracy theory'. A tactic the republican party today grabs at every chance it gets...What a dangerous precedent those two have set for today's political climate.
Solrac (1 month ago)
Bloop 545 I think she called it that because the druge report was reporting a lot of things even she didn’t know
James Sheehy (1 month ago)
I did not have several relations with that woman
Shivanshu Sharma (1 month ago)
1:45 Bill's bodily fluid, Lol call it as it is. He cummed on her dress.
Adam Brady (10 days ago)
CUCUMBER DRESSING
Existence Defies Logic (1 month ago)
+Donald West my mom has diarrhea. Have fun, "Ye" LMAO
Terrence Morrison (1 month ago)
Bill came on my dress too.
Donald West (1 month ago)
Shivanshu Sharma shut up
Donald West (1 month ago)
Existence Defies Logic shut up bitch. I’ll eat your moms ass
Ganesh Singh (1 month ago)
Linda trip or whatever her name is She will be in hell. What a friend !!
Darren Chan (1 month ago)
Logan Bennie she did it for clout
P La (1 month ago)
+Logan Bennie baahaaa you think Linda Tripp broke gf code for the good of our country??? Not hardly
Ganesh Singh (1 month ago)
+Logan Bennie in my opinion i need a good friend than a good nation
Logan Bennie (1 month ago)
Ganesh Singh what is worth more? A friendship? Or exposing the President's lies and coverups for the good of the nation
Ky Nguyen (1 month ago)
At least his stated an apologize not like Trump
Vasting (1 month ago)
Ky Nguyen trump has never been proven guilty :)
rosana conta3 (1 month ago)
Ele não pediu desculpas e já falou em entrevista.
Jeremy Smith (1 month ago)
A visual timeline... I'm nervous
ding dong (1 month ago)
Hillary deserves better she should have had more respect for herself and left the men who cheated on her
ding dong (1 month ago)
+Nikola GOATic yeah I still don't think that means anyone deserves to be cheated on. serial killers. maybe
Nikola GOATic (1 month ago)
+ding dong Of course it's not in the same way, I'm just saying they both have done bad things, is that wrong?
ding dong (1 month ago)
+Nikola GOATic not in the same way fam
Nikola GOATic (1 month ago)
+ding dong The emails...? She should be in jail right now cause of that. She threatened the security of the country for reasons we still don't know. What Bill did was wrong no doubt about it, I'm just saying they're both cheaters.
ding dong (1 month ago)
+Nikola GOATic what did she do? It doesn't matter what she did bill should not have cheated simple as that cheating is disgusting ignore everything she did it's about the cheating If my kid breaks something am I going to starve him or hit him? No they broke something that's it everyone does things
Jessie Lewis (1 month ago)
At least Bill admitted to something which is novel to our current administration 🤔
Walter De wit (1 month ago)
Even in 2018. It still smells fishy. But we got Trump now so . . .
Carl Maiwald (1 month ago)
What an evil bitch.. I'm so glad she lost the election
Anthony Jagers (1 month ago)
WOW! This is the first time I am ever even seeing video of the impeachment proceedings. I thought it was down the rabbit hole it went. Quite the contrast with the way Watergate is handled by the media.
The Other Side (1 month ago)
+Anthony Jagers *Alright then.* *VHS isn't that old though. We had 3 while growing up.* *Survived more than CDs.*
Anthony Jagers (1 month ago)
+The Other Side - Nope. The use of the term "video' might have a different meaning from someone older who is used to watching t.v. with their rabbit ears. When I think of video I think of VHS tapes. In contrast, here we have yet another movie about watergate. That was the point I was making.
The Other Side (1 month ago)
+Anthony Jagers *This contradicts your previous statement.*
Anthony Jagers (1 month ago)
+The Other Side - I saw it live in '99.
The Other Side (1 month ago)
*I am in Africa and saw this video as a kid in the 1999.* *Are you one of those who don't pay attention to news?*
Logan X Hebda (1 month ago)
The Clintons are such criminals
Anonymous Person (1 month ago)
Damn.. she looked rough for a 23 year old
VAWN (29 days ago)
She looks way better now
Existence Defies Logic (1 month ago)
+bb77077 don't be a jackass, please.
bb77077 (1 month ago)
Jessica N did I strike a chord, perhaps an-age sensitive one? Younger and older men would love to have younger women. Helen of Troy was not a cougar, you might want to think about that Jessica. As a woman, either you age well, or you get traded in. Take your pick.
Jessica N (1 month ago)
bb77077 Said the lonely virgin.
bb77077 (1 month ago)
Anonymous Person white girls age horribly. They’re best used before 28 years old.
CA C (1 month ago)
SLICK WILLY AND HILDABEAST ARE AN EMBARRASSMENT TO THIS COUNTRY.
Derik O'Brain (1 month ago)
By stopping Hillary i have stopped this sex maniac from re-entering the oval office.
Derik O'Brain (1 month ago)
+Beth Ní Dhúbhghaill I didnt vote Trump. I didnt vote at all. And i am glad. Clintons' are the lowest political scum in the country and a blot on democrats. Bernie would be a sure winner against the orange monster, but no, clintons had to ruin it.
Beth Ní Dhúbhghaill (1 month ago)
Well Hillary’s not a sex maniac is she? So no, no you didn’t stop a sex maniac from getting into the Oval Office you helped one get in for voting for trump
ellakruz (1 month ago)
Derik O'Brain oh *you* stopped Hillary, *you* stopped a sex maniac? Get over yourself. :P
CYP0 (1 month ago)
Just imagine if Hillary had become President and had an affair with a young male intern. Sweet revenge. Bill might just be grateful that his wife did not win the election.
Нилл (1 month ago)
CYP0 if she had became President Bill would continue raping young women in the White House and she would say nothing. They both are sociopaths, worse than Trump
unpaid troll (1 month ago)
somehow the cigar always gets left out. #monicaFlavoredCigars
David miorgan (1 month ago)
The Democrat controlled senate aquits Clinton even though he admits lying under oath, and worse lied to the American public! Need one say more? The deep state, the deep throat, and the american people in deep shit!
Safiya Roble (4 days ago)
David miorgan actually it was 15 Republicans in the senate who saved Clinton’s ass lol go and take your meds loony tune
David miorgan (1 month ago)
But but but he said he loved me! WAAAA. WAAAA OH BY THE WAY I'M JEWISH SO I WILL TELL EVERYONE! Later Soros buys her a new house and car!
Derek Thompson (1 month ago)
Linda Tripp always looked like she had just smelled a silent fart... such was the era of the Clintons, I suppose...
Warren Goss (1 month ago)
Bill Clinton is a serial rapist and Hillary Clinton helps him to make more victims.
John Berger (1 month ago)
Q: What's the difference between Hillary Clinton and a bowling ball? A: If you REALLY had to, you could eat a bowling ball!
how is an Affair a scandal? AN affair implies a mutual agreement. stop making this an issue -
Ambereigh (1 month ago)
Jack Otheshadows she was not stupid or a child. She consented it was mutual stop making it into something it wasn’t
P La (1 month ago)
+Tyler McQuien She Wasn't raped ! She had an affair big difference
+Tyler McQuien "let's look at the rates that Bill Clinton has been accused of the many many rapes that he's been accused of prior to him even becoming Governor." whose stupid ? hey stupid , did he lose his law lic. for the unproven allegations or not being truthfull about having grown up sex ?
Tyler McQuien (1 month ago)
+Political accountable Theory this day in age? I'm talking to a Moron. Absolutely convicted. He lost his bar license because of it. He also had to pay Paula Jones $900,000 I believe.
Susan Pepper (1 month ago)
THE RAPIST IN CHIEF AND HILLARY HIS ENABLER WIFE...
Bat Man (1 month ago)
reopen #meetoo and nail this rapist.
Joe Lavigne (1 month ago)
if I were bill I would have made Monica swallow
P No (1 month ago)
I admire her you were takken advantage of so young. Hold your head up high and move on!
Dios Sea Contigo (2 months ago)
Clintons are evil. I am certain that I can find at least five wronged females to back that statement.
Paul Carter (2 months ago)
Leftism will always get away with allsorts but one little word from a right all hell breaks loose. Dont know why but that is the world we live in. Its bastard infuriating.
Art7962 (2 months ago)
Santa Mónica
Melanie Bradley (2 months ago)
It's ironic watching this now since the Kavanaugh situation. I remember how the women who accused Clinton of sexual assualt were villianized. He was assumed innocent. 20 years later we have not come a long way baby. The pendulum has just swung in the opposite direction. Hopefully it will not take another 20 years for us to find some middle ground.
Nikola GOATic (1 month ago)
Yeah because Christine Ford is one baddie who you have to rape, right?
Samuel Fantoni (1 month ago)
+Sausage Cream If I was sexually abused, I would want justice done, just like Terry Crews when he was sexually abused. I don't think PTSD would prevent anyone from wanting their abuser to be tried and convicted. In fact, it would make their family and friends even more infuriated to have them condemned! Also, there is no way Kavanaugh's accusers could have proved that he sexually abused her. There's no evidence and no trustworthy witnesses because this happened more than 30 years ago! What if a friend of yours in high school 30 years ago was suddenly accused by a woman that he raped her. You know that your friend is not that type of guy and wasn't in high school. Furthermore, she has no evidence! Her accusation would be dismissed after a quick trial, if the jury and judge are unbiased. This is not the case with Judge Kavanaugh because this is politics we're dealing with! I believe Tom Robinson from To Kill a Mockingbird and Jeff Kavanaugh are in the same boat as being casualties of a prejudiced justice system when it comes to sexual abuse; in the case of Tom Robinson, race, and in the case of Kavanaugh, being a man in politics. Both shouldn't have come close to being convicted knowing the kind of people they are and with zero evidence against them, but due to people's prejudices against them, they did, and ultimately Tom Robinson died from that case. Let this listen not be wasted.
Beth Ní Dhúbhghaill (1 month ago)
Because he wasn’t being brought to trial. She was brought in to give a character analysis because he was going to be on the Supreme Court. He wasn’t found innocent or guilty. They just didn’t care
Sausage Cream (1 month ago)
+Samuel Fantoni If you honestly can't figure out why someone who was traumatized by someone and has PTSD wouldn't report their trauma immediately, then you're an absolute moron.
Samuel Fantoni (1 month ago)
Also the accusation was from more than 30 years ago. How are you supposed to prove that it happened after 30 years! Why is she only accusing him now?
WesMan (2 months ago)
Why does Bill Clinton wear boxer shorts?.... because they keep his ankles warm
Luke Lopez (1 month ago)
Na, a playa like Bill Clinton wears shiny acetate animal print man panties! Or maybe Walter White tightie whities.
P M (1 month ago)
lol brilliant
Enrique Godinez (2 months ago)
Bill Clinton is a fucking rapist yet liberals never call him out.
dnice (2 months ago)
DO they EVER get tired of lying? ANY one who voted for HILLARY should watch this
Romy'sRoots (1 month ago)
That's what politicians do...lie.
dnice I’m not saying she the best and should have been president I’m just saying she’s better than trump imo. Tbh they are both trash but Hillary is just a better human being in my opinion
meesh meesh (1 month ago)
+Abhishek Krishnan No it isn't. Our wages are stagnant and job growth is only due to an upward curve set by Obama. we're far from a livable minimum wage, millions cannot afford health insurance, he has set a dangerous social precedent since day one and continues to do so, he is now targeting the LGBT community and trying to strip trans rights. The only thing he has done remotely correct is make sure he didn't destroy the job growth that was set years ago during Obama's term. Just because more people have jobs now doesnt mean they're good jobs with acceptable wages.
Abhishek Krishnan (1 month ago)
+meesh meesh your country's economy is booming. I'm guessing you're from the us
meesh meesh (1 month ago)
Look at Trump's daily lies and continual destruction of our nation and global relations LOL
dave w (3 months ago)
All I want to know is do all Monica's boyfriends put cigars in her ass or was that just him her dad must be so proud of her
Mottahead (3 months ago)
The whole thing was a mess in my humble opinion. Young intern spending some unchecked time in close proximity with the president, by then a known cheater and womanizer - well, what do you want? If sexual chemistry is there, it's bound to happen, isn't it? She was young, so she can claim that she was very naive and wasn't aware of the potential repercussions of the whole thing. Bill, well, Bill was Bill (which doesn't make him an angel - the guy was married and had a young daughter - what was he thinking?). Yet what makes it more strange was Hillary Clinton's reaction to the whole thing. She always defended her husband in public, yet I would dare people to find any footage of genuine public tenderness between Bill and Hillary after he became president. Why didn't she file for divorce once it became clear that he did indeed cheated on her (and perhaps not for the first time)? Perhaps because she had political ambitions of her own and being a divorced woman would constitute a campaign liability (I'm just running my keyboard here). The whole thing was a mess and the fact that the media demonized Monica Lewinsky and sort of gave Hillary Clinton a free pass was disgusting. And we all have to remember that Congress voted to impeach Clinton, who was later saved by the Senate. His tryst with an intern had serious repercussions - Bill Clinton wasn't able to support Al Gore during Gore's presidential campaign, which might be a factor on George Bush being elected (close election - votes having to be recounted and all that mess).
rayminthecat (3 months ago)
It was a witch hunt. No collusion. Started by digging up 20yr old dirt on a real estate deal...

Would you like to comment?

Join YouTube for a free account, or sign in if you are already a member.